The logic of will, discipline and communication

home  •  logic  •  workbook  •  services  •  sources 

 

 

 

 

 


FREUD  was pessimistic about the conflict between individual instincts (he called them libido) and the discipline demanded by the social rules. If the latter do not take into account the individual the interest of individuals, the whole society relapses into the natural system: a totalitarian state, where unfairness and power play rule over justice.
 


Model for organisations

The logic of Feeling in Organizations can be applied at various levels: for individuals, organisations, a society, or even the historical development of science. I place emphasis on the development of people in organisations. Here, I define an organisation as a collaboration that must be predefined. The figure below illustrates a dynamic model. Factors in the natural system, the social system, and the communicative system that influence the development of capacities are connected with arrows. Some factors are reinforcing (+) while other factors have a balancing impact (-). Please note that the positive and negative signs have nothing to do with good or bad.

 

Explanation of model

The development of available capacity is paramount. This is from the viewpoint that a person’s essential purpose is to develop personal capacity and guide his/her own learning process in communication with others. The development of capacities is a learning process that is stimulated by the natural drive for development (the positive = constructive causal loop) and is also affected by rules and norms (the negative = balancing causal loop).

Applied to organisations, development is initially determined by the available capacities of people and resources. The love for the field also belongs to the natural system. In order to work together on shared goals, structures (building setup, function, rules, norms, procedures) arise along with the social system of the organisation. In both systems, we have assumptions, visions, and models of reality. The totality of models of reality comprises the logic of the organisation. My hypothesis is: the greater an organisation’s capacity to develop itself, the greater the potential influence on the environment as a result of reinforced capability to learn and perform actions.

Models of reality have limitations by their very nature. After all, they determine what belongs and what doesn’t. Furthermore, a conflict can arise between the logic of persons and of the organisation. To enable further development, a new system is needed, that can integrate the natural system and social system. This system arises if new visions and models can arise in communication with the environment. In the communicative system of the organisation rules, norms, procedures, and structures are tested against the values of individuals and the objectives of the organisation.

Feeling in Organizations, discipline, and communication: all three matter

My conclusion is that the identity of organisations is developed in more than one system. I have called the drive towards development the will to learn, to experiment. Discipline determines how to enable coordinated collaboration. But it also determines whether it is permitted to make mistakes and learn from them. Excessive discipline inhibits learning and stifles creativity. Communicating about the models of reality makes new learning processes possible. As the communicative system is further developed, not only does one “learn” more (development of capacities), but learning capability (determining what and how you want to learn) increases as well.

A person’s feeling plays a crucial role in the development of systems. The feeling points to the steering intentions. In new situations, steering codes must be redefined. It is important to examine what systems the steering codes come from, because the learning processes will be misguided if you are trying to explain a phenomenon from one system with explanations from another system.

Development in time

If you take the central variable, the development of capacities, from the above model and spread it out over time, you will see how one system continues building on the other. The grey area indicates what will happen in extreme cases (too much or too little steering in the system). First, the natural system of internal steering arises. Next, the social system of external steering. Finally, the communicative system of self-steering.


 

Go to logic and consultancy

Back to top of page